Connect with us

A.L. Central

Prince Fielder or C.J. Wilson a better move for Detroit?

For the record this is a friendly debate between myself and Chuck Pittman on what would have been the better move with the benefit of hind site. Not to brag but I posted the Tigers would be in the Fielder hunt after Victor Martinez went down. I, obviously, will be taking the side of Prince Fielder and Chuck will take C.J. Wilson.

Corey D. Roberts (Prince Fielder):

The facts (also the occasional opinion):

For starters, in this debate let me first say that I totally respect Chuck and his baseball knowledge. I would also like to add that this may be an attempt on his part for an unconventional approach. With that being said, Chuck are you nuts? The comparison of these 2 players is like comparing Superman to Napoleon Dynamite. When a team has the chance to add a future all-time great and Hall of Fame candidate, you should never pass up that opportunity if its feasible. What makes this deal for Fielder a home run is he is joining forces with one of the top 2 right-handed sluggers in the midst of his prime. This gives Detroit an advantage over almost every single major league team they face. The righty/lefty combo also adds a nice value at the 3/4 spots in the batting order, for obvious reasons (I am assuming that all who read this are baseball knowledgeable, I would hope! LOL). The fact that they are 27/28 years old means that their best years will be at least the next 7 years, seeing as they both play in the AL and both at some point can man the DH/1B spots (even though Cabrera will man 3B for a while), which are less than demanding defensively. Now lets talk numbers that these 2 titans can/will produce over the next 7-9 years. Miguel Cabrera averages a .950 OPS, 38 doubles, 31 HR, 109 RBI per season, and has only batted under .320 twice (forgetting his rookie season in which he only played 80 games or so). Prince Fielder averages a .930 OPS, 33 HR, 94 RBI, and has had well over 100 walks in each of the last 3 seasons. Imagine what their numbers will look like hitting next to each other in the line-up. The truth is, numbers only say so much. There is not one pitcher in baseball that wants to face these two by themselves, let alone back to back in a line up. They both have the clutch factor to add to the rest of their talents, and could easily carry a team through a round or two of so-so pitching performances. Prince and Miggy are 2 hall of fame players who will be the best 3/4 duo in baseball for the next 6 years, and maybe of all time!

lets talk money:

This is a simple answer. Yes, the Tigers spent $130 million or so more on Fielder, and 4 more years than Wilson. How much revenue does Wilson generate by just showing up to the park? The answer is none! While Fielder cost a ton more, the Tigers will enjoy a big return on investment for that extra cash spent on him. I am sure ESPN, Fox, and TBS will be falling over themselves to nationally televise the Tigers. If they pass on Fielder and go after Wilson, something is telling me that those organizations would not react the same way!


Now here is where Chuck will hang his proverbial hat. Yes, Cabrera is an average fielder at best, and yes, fielder is not a gold glover. I can give you countless examples of players that were great defenders and no matter how much they tried, they were never on the same planet as these two gentlemen at the plate. On the other hand, I can name countless average defenders that worked their butts off and wound up winning gold gloves at the corner positions. Who is to say that Cabrera will be at 3B long anyway? The probability of them both being at the DH and 1B spots for the majority of their time together with Detroit is very likely. Defense is not and will not be a factor here.

Tigers team needs:

There is an argument when it comes to “depth” at starting pitching. While one could argue that Verlander is the best right-handed starter in the game, one could not argue that they have great depth at starter either. I do not see a clear number 2 on their staff. The question is, does Wilson give them a stud number two that most great teams need? The answer is an emphatic, NO! I could argue on many points that Scherzer will put up the same, if not better, numbers than C.J. Wilson this season. I will leave that to Chuck as to why I am a dope! I can see Detroit potentially having trouble with Anaheim if they meet in October. I do think they will need another stud starting pitcher to be a major contender for the World Series, but C.J. Wilson is not the answer.

Wrap up:

In conclusion, the right decision was made by the Tigers management in going after a bona fide stud who plays every day. Prince will be an all time great. Passing on an average major league pitcher for a lofty 16 million a year, with no R.O.I. opportunity, was a wise decision.

Chuck Pittman (C.J. Wilson):

First off, thank you for the nice comments at the beginning of your post. I respect your opinion as well. With that being said…

From the offensive point of view, the lefty/ righty combination is something to marvel at indeed. We all know what these two have done up until this moment with the bat. My explanation as to why this was a bad decision will not be centered around that. As you have alluded, my argument will be aimed at 3 aspects:

#1: The defensive ramifications of this move
#2: The financial ramifications of this move
#3: What they should have done with the 200+ million

I will also address Corey’s ludicrous statement regarding CJ Wilson, and have a final point unmentioned before.


Let me take you back to 2007. You will notice that out of 22 qualifying 3rd basemen, Miguel Cabrera was 20th in fielding percentage in front of Ryan Braun (who no longer plays 3rd base), and Kevin Kousmanoff (who has been a complete bust of a prospect). Outside of Ryan Braun, Cabrera tied Zimmerman for the most errors as a 3rd baseman. Keep in mind that Zimmerman had 511 total chances, whereas Cabrera only had 389 chances, therefore it is safe to say that Cabrera was the worst defensive 3rd baseman in the big leagues.

Do you want me to believe that this guy can simply slide over to man the Hot Corner after a 4 year hiatus, and it’s not a big deal??? There are 3 aspects to baseball, gentlemen. They are pitching, defense, and offense. The San Francisco Giants recently proved that you can win a World Series by being great at pitching and defense and have an offense that is slightly better than a Triple A team, and every single year, the New York Yankees prove that stacking your team with High priced offensive players won’t win you anything in October. The cliché that “great pitching beats great hitting” is not a cliché, it’s a fact!!


It’s true that sponsorship-wise, they will make some of their money back, as you can expect to see a lot of the Tigers on National Television. If you know anything about money-ball, you must know something about buying wins. How many wins did this move actually buy? Last year the Red Sox, Yankees, and Rangers finished 1,2,3 in total runs scored with the Tigers following at the 4th position. Exactly what did this move do to change that?? The Yankees, Red Sox, and Rangers still have a better lineup. They still have a better pitching rotation than the Tigers. They might be slightly better than the Rangers pitching staff because they lost Wilson, but they did add Darvish and Feliz to their rotation so the book is still out for the Rangers.

My point is that overall, this move has done nothing to change the team in terms of overall improvement. The Tigers are still weak in their starting pitching rotation, and their offense is still a Top 4 offensive team. This move will give up more runs in the long-term, and by long-term I mean how long they signed Fielder for. Miguel Cabrera will eventually return to 1st base, and Fielder will move to DH. DH’ing is a bit harder than it seems. It’s not easy, and Fielder has no experience with it. When that time comes, we’ll see how he adapts. How much financial wiggle room will they have in the future by having Miggy and Fielder locked up for so much money until 2016?


CJ Wilson was a free agent this off-season. Since the owner wanted to spend some big bucks this off-season, it would have been a wise decision to spend that money on an actual team weakness i.e. Pitching!! Wilson actually got better in his 2nd year of starting by cutting his walks significantly down (93 to 74), and his strikeouts actually rose (170 to 206). That’s not normally how it goes. Usually more command = less strikeouts. They could have signed Wilson for 80 million/ 5 years which is basically the same contract they gave Verlander, and they still would’ve had plenty of cash to make another signing.

Miscellaneous Points:

Corey said that Max Scherzer is equal to CJ Wilson, but I just don’t buy that. Scherzer is no young puppy either considering the fact he will be 28 this year. If you’re still waiting for a “Breakout year,” you will be sadly disappointed. He is what he is, and that is an inconsistent starter whom you should be terrified to see on the mound for your favorite team in the playoffs, however, as a #3 or#4 starter you should feel comfortable. CJ Wilson is as consistent as they come, and now this season he will be pitching in a Top 5 ball park for pitchers (in Anaheim) as opposed to pitching in the #1 Home Run hitting ball park (Texas).

To say that Max Scherzer is a better pitcher and/or fantasy option than CJ Wilson is a ridiculous statement. Waiting on a mythical “Breakout” campaign for Scherzer is even more ridiculous. The Tigers don’t have a #2 pitcher. Doug Fister isn’t the answer, and Scherzer damn sure isn’t either.


Granted, Fielder lost some weight this past off-season, but I think his overall physical fitness will always be a risk. When you add to the fact that Miggy’s physical fitness and prior alcohol problems is also a risk, this might shape up to be a disaster if certain things fall into place. To call Fielder a Hall of Fame caliber player is stretching it a bit. Fielder has alternated great seasons with average seasons despite having a great lineup-protecting, superstar batting side by side with him the last 4 years.

The Tigers would have been better off signing a starter like CJ Wilson. If they wanted a 1 year rental to DH until VMART comes back they could have signed Carlos Pena. Instead they went over board by locking up Fielder for close to a decade. We will see how this works out. In the meantime the Tigers will be an exciting team to watch that will put up a lot of runs, but what else is new? They were already a Top 4 offense. NOTHING HAS CHANGED!!.

Owner and creator of Major League Fantasy Sports. We will provide you with the best tools to be successful in your leagues no matter if it's daily, seasonal, or expert driven!



  1. Corey D Roberts

    January 29, 2012 at 3:50 am

    My argument is only whether you take Fielder over C.J. Wilson and nothing more. (Fantasy or reality) I recognize that Detroit has a major need for a second starter similar to Anaheim to be a contender for winning the fall classic. Also, who is to say that Detroit does not go after more pitching via trade this year or free agent next year. Then where do we stand? My contention is that C.J. Wilson is not a number 2 and is not worth 16 million per season for 5 years and Fielder is an everyday player that has the kind of talent that is not very common. That is right about the same as Verlander who is, lets say, 100 times better.

  2. 65mustangs

    January 29, 2012 at 4:38 am

    This was a fun read. I have to give the W to Corey though. Of course he had the advantage of writing about the actual signing, whereas Chuck was writing about a hypothetical signing. Where I disagree with Chuck though, and to some extent Corey, are the assumptions that these teams could just do whatever they wanted. Perhaps the Tigers never even had a shot at C.J. Wilson. He may have wanted to stay in TX or move to the West Coast. His agent may have used the Tiger’s possible interest as a bargaining chip. Chuck also said they could have just used the money saved to sign Carlos Pena. How do we know they didn’t try to? How do we know Pena wanted any part of Detroit? Where would you rather live 6 months out of the year, Detroit or Tampa? No offense to the fine people of Detroit, but we’re talking year round sun and beaches here.
    I also highly doubt that the owner and GM of Detroit made a knee-jerk move to the tune of over $200M. Those negotiations were going on for a long time. Scott Boras is the most shrewd agent in the game, probably to it’s detriment, but that is another story for another time. I’m sure he pounced all over the V-Mart injury and used it as bargaining leverage, but do you really think Ilitch would make a $200M panic move like it was Fantasy Baseball? I don’t. Boras’ clients are the last to sign every year. He holds up the game to get the very last dollar out there. He does not react to market trends, he is the market trend setter. I’m sure Boras had several multi-year, multi-nine figure deals in his pocket when they accepted the Tigers offer. He knows the market better than anyone; and anyone who thinks Boras was not in control this whole time is not paying attention. The Tigers were probably dreaming about a Miggy, Fielder, V-Mart murders row, and that would have made this debate a bit different.
    Finally, and this is me going out on a limb, but why can’t Scherzer put it together at 28? (He won’t be 28 until 4 months into the season) That is not old for a SP by any means. That is prime time. He has only been a starter in MLB for 3.5 seasons, and had a league change to the tougher league. He has not yet cracked 200IP in a season. He lowered his BB/9 and increased his K/BB dramatically in 2011 while enduring a .316 BaBip, a career high. I’m not saying he is Randy Johnson but RJ had his “breakout” season at age 30. Guess how old CJ Wilson was in 2010 when he had his “breakout season”. Yup, he turned 30 right after that season, and has only been a starter for 2 seasons. The Yankees passed on Wilson because he turns 32 in 2012 and has pitched 480 innings in the last 2 seasons including post season play after being a reliever for his whole career prior to that. Is he a better pitcher than Scherzer right now? Of course. Is he 80 Million better over the next 5 years? Will he be worth $16M when he is 37? Well, no, neither will Fielder be, but Fielder has a better chance of still being an elite run producer at 37 than does CJ of still being a borderline ace caliber pitcher.
    So, I think the Tigers were better off signing Fielder than CJ, assuming they had a choice. Of course the Angels signed CJ on top of hauling in Pujols. The Tigers cannot trump that, even though I agree that they are probably still a SP away from the top of the heap. Maybe Turner will be that guy? But the reason I give the W to Corey is not because I agree with his side of the argument, but that I thought his argument was more accurate, and less based on supposition.
    Thanks, this was fun. I guess now I have too much time on my hands. 🙂

    Joe Iannone
    65Mustangs (ESPN FBB Boards)

  3. Corey D Roberts

    January 29, 2012 at 11:32 am

    Very good job Joe (65 mustangs)! I change my vote, I think Joe won. LOL

  4. Corey D Roberts

    January 29, 2012 at 11:49 am

    I think the number logic and information on Wilson is spot on. Kind of put the finishing touches on Wilson I think! I know Chuck will enjoy responding to your post. Thanks for taking the time and we look forward to having similar discussions in the near future. Cheers.

  5. 65mustangs

    January 29, 2012 at 1:19 pm

    My pleasure. And, Chuck, I hope you realize I was not picking on you. You had the tougher argument from the start.

    • cdub2k

      January 29, 2012 at 2:56 pm

      No problem. It was an argument I wanted to make.

  6. Mateo Fischer

    February 5, 2012 at 11:17 am

    I personally like Fielder a whole lot more. What I can’t believe wasn’t brought up is that Fielder will only be a year older than Wilson when both of their contracts are up. I do not, though, agree with the “everyday player” argument dictating that Starting Pitchers are one fifth as valuable as hitter, because a pitcher has control of half of the game every fifth day as the hitter has control of 1/9th of half of the game everyday. You then factor in how many innings the pitchers goes of the full 9, the hitters’ defense, and you have a true value comparison.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Help Support Our Growth!

Major League Fantasy Baseball Show Episode #167, 6/23/2019 Host Brian Roach, Jr., Co-Host Cole Freel, Guest Kevin Bzdek

Major League Fantasy Baseball Show Episode #169, 8/4/2019 Host Cole Freel, Guest Joe Iannone

Radio Show Feed

Blog Authors

avatar for Ben WardiBen Wardi

I am a recent college graduate from a small liberal arts school in Atlanta, GA. I'm a sports junkie and a diehard Atlanta sports fan.

avatar for Brandon ZimanBrandon Ziman

Grew up playing baseball since I could hold a bat. Played baseball through high school and college. Somehow became a Yankee fan even though I ...

avatar for Brian Roach, JrBrian Roach, Jr

Baseball fan through and through. Follows every team, every player and every transaction. Graduated Lasell College in 2013. Covers high sc...

avatar for Bryan LuhrsBryan Luhrs

Faith, Family and Fantasy Sports.These are the three words that best describe me. I am a faithful husband and father of 6 amazing children. I ...

avatar for Cole FreelCole Freel

Bachelors in English and History from Indiana University. Borderline-Obsessed Fantasy Baseball Writer who also dabbles in Football, Basketball...

avatar for Corey D RobertsCorey D Roberts

Owner and creator of Major League Fantasy Sports. We will provide you with the best tools to be successful in your leagues no matter if ...

avatar for Geordie EasterbrookGeordie Easterbrook

I’m a former pitcher from upstate New York, and a proud Demon Deacon. Go Deacs! I’ve been playing fantasy football and baseball for the be...

avatar for James WilkJames Wilk

I grew up a Dallas Cowboy's fan in Washington Redskins' country, but I currently reside in Florida. I have played fantasy sports since 1999,...

avatar for Joe IannoneJoe Iannone

I'm an accountant and an amateur writer of fiction and sports commentary, mostly baseball. I've been a student of the game of baseball since...

avatar for Kevin BzdekKevin Bzdek

I've been playing fantasy baseball for 14 years. I am also an auditor and CPA, where I analyze information on a daily basis. Combined, my pas...

avatar for Kyle AmoreKyle Amore

I'm a former collegiate and semi-pro baseball player. I underwent successful Tommy John Surgery in 2008, and can give a wide-range of tips on...

avatar for Mark RushMark Rush

Unrepentant Red Sox fan and all things Boston. Deflategate was a joke. Boston Latin School is awesome. Harvard and Johns Hopkins alma mater...

avatar for Matt BarkmanMatt Barkman

A/S/ the old school AOL instant messenger days...
Elementary Physical Education by day, chasing around my 1 and 2 year old boy...

avatar for Mike RiggallMike Riggall

I've been coaching lacrosse since 2002 and playing fantasy football since 2006. I've racked up several championships over the years includi...

avatar for Nick GehlbachNick Gehlbach

Husband and father of three. Have a love of all things baseball. When not burying myself in baseball (especially fantasy) I enjoy fish...

avatar for Todd NevinTodd Nevin

A business analyst by day, pursuing all things baseball by night. My favorite day of the year is opening day and my favorite sound is the crac...

@brandonziman You are more than welcome Brandon. You were a fantastic writer and a joy to work with. As we move through a very big transition for us hopefully we can continue to work with one anither.

About 4 months ago from Corey Roberts's Twitter via Twitter for Android

Help Support Our Growth!

More in A.L. Central